Why Prostitution, The World's Oldest Job is Illegal? Let's Talk About Why!
Everybody calls prostitution the "world's oldest profession," right? But here's the thing: in most places today, it's totally illegal and super-policed. So, what's the big deal? What are we really trying to stop when two adults agree on a price for sex in private? It's confusing!
You can legally pay someone for sex on camera, or shower a "non-marital partner" with gifts and rent money—that's generally fine. But cash for sex in a hotel room? Boom, you're a criminal. That inconsistency tells us this isn't just about good vs. evil or germs. We've gotta dig into how prostitution went from just being a regular thing to being a crime, and who pushed for those changes.
History is Weird: Prostitution Was State-Run!
For centuries—I mean, a huge chunk of history—prostitution wasn't just allowed, it was often managed and even taxed by the government and religious leaders!
Think about ancient Mesopotamia; the temple priests ran the brothels for the goddess Ishtar. The Greeks cranked this up, using state-owned brothels to bring in serious cash for public projects. The high-end workers were educated and respected! Rome did the same, taxing the business that was literally everywhere.
But then Christianity shows up, and things get moody. The Church called sex outside marriage a sin. Still, even big thinkers like St. Augustine were like, "Look, we gotta have it, or things will get way worse!"
The real hammer dropped later, though, thanks to two big things: the syphilis outbreak around 1494 and the Protestant Reformation. Protestants saw brothels as Catholic corruption, and everyone got scared of disease. So, by the 1600s, BAM! Prostitution was banned across most of Europe.
The Usual Suspects: What They Say Is the Problem
We usually hear three main reasons why this job is against the law, but they kind of fall flat when you look closely:
Stop the Bad Guys: This is the big one today: Protecting Against Exploitation and trafficking. Sure, the government busts awful trafficking rings with real victims—kids and people who are struggling. But here's the catch: the folks against legalization worry that making sex work legal would just let traffickers hide their victims easily. The weird part? Voluntary sex work gets mixed up with forced trafficking, and who actually gets arrested the most? Not the expensive escorts, but the most broke women on the streets.
Keep Us Healthy: Public Health has been a reason for centuries. But wait—if health is the real issue, why not just regulate it? Places like Nevada, with legalized brothels, prove that mandatory testing and condoms can drop STD rates to almost nothing. Regulation is way smarter than pushing everything into the shadows!
No More Eyesores: This is the Nuisance Factor. When it's visible, people complain. Neighbors don't want cars circling or people hanging around. That's why discretion is key: if you meet quietly and go to a hotel, no one notices. But if you're doing business on the street, people want you gone.
These are real issues, but they don't explain why this one job is illegal almost everywhere when other super-dangerous or even exploitative jobs—like coal mining, or renting your womb as a surrogate—are called "honest work." Something else is going on!
The Secret Reason: Keeping the Family Together
Okay, here's the deeper reason, the one nobody likes to say out loud: It's all about strengthening the family unit.
For a long time, both the church and the state have wanted strong families. Why? Because strong families mean stable communities: less crime, higher income, and better-educated kids. The government encourages this with tax breaks and financial protections for married folks.
Now, think about marriage. It's a deal that guarantees commitment, resources, and sexual partnership. But if paid sex is easily available, it changes the game. Why would a guy commit to the headaches, conflicts, and responsibilities of marriage when he can just pay for what he wants and walk away?
Look, that's oversimplifying things—relationships are much more than sex!—but it's a huge factor. We've already seen that as morals loosened over the past 50 years, and sex outside marriage became okay, marriage rates dropped. Legalizing prostitution would just throw gas on that fire, and it would totally undermine the institution of marriage that society relies on.
The Key Player: What Women Want
To actually get these laws passed, you needed political power, and guess what? That came mostly from women.
Check the stats: in almost every country, women are much, much less likely than men to support legalizing prostitution—by about $10 \text{ to } 20$ percentage points! Men often talk about "freedom of choice," but women usually call it "exploitation."
The big "purity crusades" in the late 1800s were fueled by women's groups, especially once they got the right to vote. They used the Church's language of sin and moral decay, but they also had practical reasons: they didn't want their husbands spending family money on brothels or bringing home diseases. This coalition was powerful enough to pass landmark laws like the Mann Act (1910).
The bottom line is this: Prostitution is illegal almost everywhere because it's not merely a libertarian issue of consenting adults. It's the result of combined pressure from religious leaders, governments wanting social stability, and, most decisively, organized women's groups providing the political push to criminalize an activity perceived to destabilize family life.
About the Writer
Jenny, the tech wiz behind Jenny's Online Blog, loves diving deep into the latest technology trends, uncovering hidden gems in the gaming world, and analyzing the newest movies. When she's not glued to her screen, you might find her tinkering with gadgets or obsessing over the latest sci-fi release.What do you think of this blog? Write down at the COMMENT section below.
No comments:
Post a Comment